The Best Broiler Pans

Broiler Pans: Reviews, Top Picks & FAQ

πŸ₯‡ Rank #1
Wilton
92 %
βœ”οΈ Highly Recommended!
πŸ₯ˆ Rank #2
Cuisinart
90 %
βœ”οΈ Highly Recommended!
πŸ₯‰ Rank #3
Nordic Ware
87 %
βœ”οΈ Recommended!
We are supported by your purchases when you click on our links. Listed prices may not always reflect the most recent price. Prices were last updated on 2020-05-25 06:53:59 PM. Learn more about our Product & Pricing Disclaimer.

How we Reviewed and Ranked Broiler Pans

To create our buying guide for the best broiler pans of May 2020, we analyzed 3,140 user reviews across 7 products with an average user rating of 4.2 stars. Our scoring algorithms remove fake reviews, consider expert reviews on other websites and monitor search engine interest to determine our confidence in your satisfaction with your purchase.
7
Products Reviewed
3,140
Reviews Analyzed
4.2 ⭐
Average User Rating
$29.53
Average Price
84%
Average ProductAdvisor Score
divider graphic

The Best Broiler Pans of May 2020


Rank #1


βœ”οΈ We Highly Recommend This Product!
10
Reviews Analyzed
4.6 ⭐
Average User Rating
$46.85
Latest Price
92%
Our Score

Non-stick steel broiler pan from Wilton.

Key Features

  • Lightweight with gunmetal finishing.
  • Large 17-inch width accommodate large food.
  • Made of high-quality steel material.
  • Features non-stick coating to make cleaning easier.
Rank #2


βœ”οΈ We Highly Recommend This Product!
807
Reviews Analyzed
4.5 ⭐
Average User Rating
$32.77
Latest Price
90%
Our Score

Stainless steel quality broiler rack.

Key Features

  • Has a glowing stainless steel finishing.
  • Features riveted stainless steel handles.
  • Designed to allow for drip-free pouring.
  • Features dishwasher-safe parts.
Rank #3


βœ”οΈ We Recommend This Product!
1,472
Reviews Analyzed
4.1 ⭐
Average User Rating
$9.95
Latest Price
87%
Our Score

Aluminum Nordic Ware broiler pan.

Key Features

  • Can be used on toaster ovens, RV and camping stoves.
  • 2-piece design ensures you won't have smokey meals.
  • Non-stick surface ensures easy cleanup.
  • Large 8.5-inch cooking surface.
Rank #4


βœ”οΈ We Recommend This Product!
249
Reviews Analyzed
4.3 ⭐
Average User Rating
$21.40
Latest Price
86%
Our Score

A quality Whirlpool broiler pan with rack.

Key Features

  • Made from high-quality porcelain material.
  • Comes with a roasting rack and a metal grid.
  • Easy to clean and replace after each use.
  • Serves as a replacement for a variety of model numbers.
Rank #5


βœ”οΈ We Recommend This Product!
10
Reviews Analyzed
4.1 ⭐
Average User Rating
$12.18
Latest Price
82%
Our Score

A healthy way to cook meats, roasts, fish and chicken. This small 2-piece non-stick broiler pan set lets grease drain off while cooking, so you still get delicious flavor without all the fat.

Key Features

  • Has a 5-year limited warranty on it.
  • Features dishwasher safe parts.
  • Made of a combo of steel and non-stick materials.
  • Comes in 2 pieces and features fat drain holes.
Rank #6


⚠️ Some Issues Reported with This Product
31
Reviews Analyzed
3.9 ⭐
Average User Rating
$33.54
Latest Price
78%
Our Score

Get replacement broiler pan for your Frigidaire oven.

Key Features

  • Serves as a replacement pan for Frigidaire range and ovens.
  • Made of porcelain-coated composite materials.
  • 2-piece design traps all juices when cooking.
  • Offers up to 12-inch of cooking space.
Rank #7


⚠️ Some Issues Reported with This Product
561
Reviews Analyzed
3.8 ⭐
Average User Rating
$50.00
Latest Price
76%
Our Score

Granite Ware dishwasher safe broiler pan set.

Key Features

  • 3-piece broiler pan set includes bake and grill pans.
  • Made from carbon steel materials.
  • Has a non-stick porcelain-coated surface.
  • The broiler pan set is dishwasher safe.

Frequently Asked Questions


The average price of a broiler pan is $29.53. They range in price from $9.95 to $50.00

The best broiler pan for the money is the Wilton 17-Inch Nonstick Broiler Pan. It costs $46.85 on Amazon.com

The cheapest broiler pan is the Nordic Ware 42210 Toaster Oven 2-Piece Broiler. It costs $9.95 on Amazon.com

divider graphic

Compare Broiler Pans

Our editors selected the following Broiler Pans for consideration in our list.
Brand Product Score Price Reviews Rating Weight Dimensions
Wilton Wilton 17-Inch Nonstick Broiler Pan 92% $46.85 10 4.6⭐ 0.00 lbs 12 W x 12 L x 4 H
Cuisinart Cuisinart 7117-16UR Chef Roaster 90% $32.77 807 4.5⭐ 6.25 lbs 20.75 W x 6.25 L x 13.25 H
Nordic Ware Nordic Ware 42210 Toaster Oven 2-Piece Broiler 87% $9.95 1,472 4.1⭐ 0.60 lbs 7 W x 10 L x 0.63 H
Whirlpool Whirlpool 4396923 Porcelain Broiler Pan 86% $21.40 249 4.3⭐ 3.00 lbs 15.83 W x 20.13 L x 2 H
Wilton Wilton Non-stick Broiler Pan Set 82% $12.18 10 4.1⭐ 0.77 lbs 2.23 W x 13.25 L x 7.98 H
Frigidaire Frigidaire 5304442087 Oven Broiler Pan 78% $33.54 31 3.9⭐ 2.50 lbs 12.6 W x 15.8 L x 2.3 H
Granite Ware Granite Ware Bake Broiler Set 76% $50.00 561 3.8⭐ 2.90 lbs 10.06 W x 15.81 L x 2.88 H
Brand Product Score Price Reviews Rating Weight Dimensions

Best Broiler Pan Brands

The following brands make the best Broiler Pans in the market.

Sources

Thank you to these resources for helping us compile this page
https://www.foodsharkmarfa.com/best-broiler-pan/
For shifting to healthy choices, broiler pan can be a good head start for you. A general broiler pan...
https://cookingmatt.com/best-broiler-pans/
β€’ Broiler pans come in a large range of sizes and materials. Some broilers are made especially for...
https://bdolan.net/best-broiler-pans/
The best broiler pans help to cook all the food you need at one time while ensuring that it’s even...
https://onthegas.org/cookware/best-broiler-pan
User reports indicate that this broiler pan holds up very well after frequent dishwasher cleaning. I...
https://www.amazon.com/best-broiler-pan/s?k=best+broiler+pan
Amazon.com: best broiler pan. ... Kitchen Basics 101 Replacement for Whirlpool 4396923 Porcelain Bro...
https://www.chefsresource.com/best-broiler-pans/
7 Nordic Ware Nonstick Broiler Pan Set. Yet another dual piece best broiler pan. The broiling rack o...
http://www.bestcovery.com/best-broiler-pan
Best Broiler Pan. Tweet. Although the use of broiler pans has declined with the advent of grill pans...
https://www.bestadvisor.com/broiler-pan
A broiler pan will let you prepare delicious meat and vegetable combos quickly and efficiently. In t...
https://smokerestaurant.com/best-broiler-pan/
It is pretty evident that broiler pans are essential because they offer a healthy alternative to pre...
https://www.bestcovery.com/best-broiler-pan
Best Broiler Pan. Chef CJ. 10.09.2013. Although the use of broiler pans has declined with the advent...
arrow-up icon